— —
Follow on X
LESSONS

How changes happen: BIPs and the people

Changes are proposed publicly as BIPs, reviewed, coded and released. They become rules only when node operators run them. Developers write; users decide.

6 MIN READ
The path from an idea to an enforced rule: discussion, BIP, code, nodes, economic majority.
LEVEL · Advanced
IN THIS LESSON · 1 OF 7
BY THE END YOU WILL BE ABLE TO ANSWER
  • What is a BIP?
  • Who ultimately decides whether a rule change is Bitcoin's rule?

Then prove it: a 2-question quiz. The lesson marks itself complete at 100%.

The BIP process

A Bitcoin Improvement Proposal is a numbered document describing a change or a standard: BIP 32 (HD wallets), BIP 39 (seed words), BIP 141 (SegWit), BIP 341 (Taproot). Anyone can write one. It is discussed on the bitcoin-dev mailing list, refined, assigned a number by the BIP editors, and may or may not ever be implemented. A BIP is a proposal, not a decision.

Bitcoin Core

The reference implementation. Code changes arrive as pull requests, reviewed publicly by other contributors, and merged by a handful of maintainers who hold commit access. Maintainers cannot force anyone to run anything; they can only decide what the Core release contains. Alternative implementations (Knots, btcd, libbitcoin) exist and must follow the same consensus rules to stay on the network.

Who decides

Nobody, which is the point, and everybody, which is the mechanism:

  • Developers propose and write code. They have influence through quality and reputation, no authority.
  • Node operators choose which software to run. A rule that nodes do not enforce is not a rule.
  • Miners signal readiness and build blocks under the rules nodes accept.
  • The economic majority (exchanges, businesses, holders) decides which chain they value. In a dispute, their choice of what to call "bitcoin" settles it.

Why it is slow

A consensus change needs near-universal adoption to avoid a split, so proposals go through years of review and must be compelling, safe and backward-compatible. Slow is the feature: it is what makes the rules credible.

Funding

Core developers are funded by grants from companies, non-profits and individuals, with no central employer. Several funding bodies exist specifically to keep development independent of any one firm.

On Bitcoin's governance · BitBlockBoom talkWatch on YouTube ↗
CHECK YOURSELF
1/2 What is a BIP?
2/2 Who ultimately decides whether a rule change is Bitcoin's rule?
pick an answer for each question

SOURCES

  1. How does Bitcoin development work? (River)
Progress is saved in this browser only.